My daughter, L, had a friend over to play last Friday. They are both a little bit shy and usually look to me to get ideas for fun things to do. We have a candy making kit, that someone gave my girls, that is supposed to be a sort of “science” experiment kit. The girls decided on chocolate caramels because they liked the sound of it in the book of recipes that is part of the kit. The book has some good ideas, but the recipes and the equipment are, in a word, useless. Their recipe for chocolate caramels had an enormous amount of molasses in it – I mean, on the order of a cup of molasses. Given I don’t make candy too often and don’t have any candy specific cookbooks, I went to the classics. First, The Joy of Cooking didn’t have anything that caught our eyes. Then, I went to another favorite “mom” type of cookbook, The New Settlement Cookbook. This cookbook is truly old fashioned and homey (my “new” copy is from 1991, the original version was printed in 1901) and says on the cover “The First Classic Collection of American Ethnic Recipes”. It is a gem. Great, simple, easy to follow recipes. I found Chocolate Caramels in the index. The girls and I made a couple of substitutions, and halved the recipe. The results were delicious, but you wouldn’t want to eat any of these if you have loose fillings!
Adapted from The New Settlement Cookbook, 1991
makes 36 1-inch squares
1 cup white sugar
1/2 cup dark brown sugar
1/2 cup corn syrup (we used light corn syrup)
1/4 cup heavy cream
4 Tbsp unsalted butter
Pinch of salt
1 1/2 oz. unsweetened chocolate
1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
Butter a piece of foil and set in a small baking pan. Fold foil to create a square 6 in. X 6 in. X 1 in. Combine all ingredients except chocolate and vanilla extract in a heavy saucepan. Cover and boil for 5 minutes. Uncover and boil to the firm ball stage, 247°F (next time, I’d go a little below this temperature for a slightly softer candy). Remove from the heat and stir in the vanilla, and then the chocolate. Pour into the buttered foil “pan”. Let cool completely.
Turn the cooled caramel square onto a cutting board and remove the foil. Mark out 1-inch squares onto the big square of caramel and cut with a greased chef’s knife. This is not that easy to do, it is pretty sticky business, and you may need to re-shape the squares a bit with your fingers. Wrap the candy in squares of waxed paper.